Tag Archives: san antonio express-news

Victim, defendant… whatever

saexpressBecause of a reporting error, a story on Thursday’s Page 2B incorrectly identified murder victim Andre Garcia. "Taz" is the nickname for defendant Roger Arias Jr.

Fuzzy numbers etc.

saexpressLast week’s story on the Stone Oak Rotary Club’s donation to SAMMinistries was in the amount of $2,500, not $25,000 as stated. Also, Rotarian Bob Bordelon is the club’s current president, not vice president as stated. We apologize for any confusion that the errors may have caused.

Plagiarism at the NY Daily News

nydailynewsAn article published on the New York Daily News’ website stole two paragraphs and two quotes from a story published on the front page of the San Antonio Express-News. Bob Richter, the Express-News public editor, described the theft on his blog:

An editor at nydailynews.com, the Web site of the New York Daily News, acknowledged Thursday that a Web reporter, Rosemary Black, lifted, without attribution, part of a Feb. 3 Express-News story.
Plagiarism, or passing off another person’s work as though it were your own, is considered a cardinal sin of journalism.
The Express-News story, “Kissing at mall leads to fight in court,” by E-N staff writer Jeorge Zarazua, was published on Page 1.

The nydailynews.com story, published online a day later, “Kissing is no crime, say women arrested in San Antonio mall,” used, without crediting the Express-News, two quotations given only to Zarazua and two paragraphs crafted by Zarazua that led into the quotes.

After hearing from the Express-News, the Daily News updated the article to include the proper attribution. The paper also appended an editor’s note:

Editor’s note: An earlier version of this story should have attributed quotes by certain individuals to reporting by the San Antonio Express-News.

This is about as weak as the paper’s earlier correction for twice misidentifying a woman as the “Manhattan Madam.” The note doesn’t mention plagiarism, and it ignores the two stolen paragraphs that preceded the copied quotes.

History lesson

saexpressBecause of a reporting error, a travel story on Sunday’s Page 2K about the Portuguese town of Oporto incorrectly stated that England colonized Portugal. England only traded with Portugal. Link

A convincing competitor

Because of an editing error, a photo on Friday’s Page 1C that accompanied a story about Apple Inc.’s iPhone showed another product. It was a Samsung Instinct.

Music columnist resigns over ghost writing scandal

This ranks as one of the stranger recent examples of journalistic malfeasance. As noted by Romenesko (and a variety of readers who sent it in), a syndicated music columnist has resigned after a paper he wrote for became aware that he had used a ghost writer “to produce more than 100 stories and columns since 2001.” From the paper’s story about Ramiro Burr:

“Ramiro caused the Express-News to unknowingly publish work under his name that was not, in fact, his own work,” said Robert Rivard, editor of the Express-News.
“It was the work of at least one other writer who did not receive credit and who we did not know about. Ramiro decided on his own to resign just as our investigation was concluding and we were preparing to take appropriate action. We have a zero-tolerance policy whenever someone on our staff presents work as their own that is not their own.”
Burr’s resignation came 24 hours after his lawyer, Glenn D. Levy, sent Rivard a letter contending that Burr is a syndicated columnist and the Express-News “never questioned” how he performed his duties…
The Express-News began to look into allegations against Burr in April after lawyers for Douglas Shannon contacted Rivard, seeking “formal byline credit” for stories Shannon claimed he “ghost-wrote” for Burr in 2001, 2002 and 2003. Shannon also claimed that he transcribed and translated from Spanish to English interviews Burr conducted in 2006, 2007 and 2008.
Shannon’s lawyers presented to Hearst Corp. lawyers a binder thoroughly documenting Shannon’s working relationship with Burr. It contained invoices, e-mail correspondence, copies of stories Shannon said he either wrote or substantially helped Burr write and other allegations, among them:
That Shannon wrote all 80 of Burr’s Latin Notes columns published in the Express-News Weekender section between Dec. 14, 2001, and June 27, 2003.
That Shannon wrote – over the same December 2001-June 2003 time frame – 24 other stories that were published under Burr’s byline, and;
That Shannon worked as Burr’s intern during that time period from the offices of Munoz Public Relations, a local firm that represents at least one musical organization (Mariachi Vargas) that fell within Burr’s beat.
Cynthia Y. Munoz, president of the firm, Wednesday confirmed the arrangement with Burr.
Shannon’s lawyers sent a similar letter to Houston Chronicle Editor Jeff Cohen, making similar claims against five articles that appeared in the Chronicle under Burr’s byline.
In their April letter to Rivard, Shannon’s lawyers described their client’s arrangement with Burr:
“On various occasions,” wrote Shannon lawyer Kenneth S. Saks, “Burr would give our client some leads to use. In most cases, after our client finished writing the drafts, he would call Burr over the phone and read aloud the article.

The full story is worth reading. This incident reminds me of a rather controversial Craigslist ad from last year. It read in part:

Looking for an experienced article ghostwriter that knows how to meet deadlines:
I do the marketing and editing, you do the research and writing. I am an experienced and published freelance writer with credits from more than 20 national publications including Woman’s Day, Oxygen, Business 2.0, For Me, Cooking Light, Men’s Journal, Backpacker, and Robb Report and I can’t execute all the ideas I have. That’s where you come in.
You will ghostwrite some of the articles for me and I will give you anywhere between $0.25 & $0.35 per word. If you dazzle me with your work, you’ll get $0.35 per word. Over time, that fee may increase to $0.40 per word.”

Some analysis of the ghostwriter issue is here.

Police photo error implicates wrong man

Because of an incorrect photo provided by the Bexar County Sheriff’s Office, a Tuesday Express-News story about a slaying suspect was accompanied by a photograph of a San Antonio man who was not connected in any way with the slaying. The story, ‘Transient’s tale ends in arrest,’ was published on Page 1A. The photo did not appear on MySanAntonio.com.
The actual suspect, Robert Patrick White, 38, described by police as a homeless man, is pictured here. White and two others have been charged with the slaying earlier this month of Christopher Duncan, a 23-year-old South Side man.
‘The wrong photo was in the wrong data file,’ Ralph G. Serrano, manager of the central records and identification section of the Sheriff’s Office, said in an e-mail to the Express-News. ‘I apologize for any embarrassment or inconvenience that this may have caused.’
The Express-News also apologizes to the misidentified man, his family and friends and to our readers.
Link

And the misidentified man is…?

Thanks, Craig!

Advice from the grave

This is a new one. A writer for the San Antonio Express-News interviewed a couple for a story about the secret to a happy marriage” and then filed the piece last summer. It was held until recently and, unfortunately, the couple died in the interim. The story didn’t note that fact. The paper decided to run a correction to inform readers. Fortunately, it appears the couple’s daughter wasn’t upset by the story:

Nell and Wallace Crain, a couple who were featured in a Page 1A story and photo on “the secret to a happy marriage,” died between the writing of the story last summer and its publication in the San Antonio Express-News on Monday. The deaths were not mentioned in the report.
The Express-News apologizes to family and friends of the couple, and to our readers, for the egregious omission.
J. Michael Parker, who wrote the story after spotting and interviewing the Crains at North Star Mall last June, said he learned of their deaths Monday via an e-mail from a Crain family friend. The friend put Parker in touch with Cheryl Crain Sanders, the couple’s daughter, who was gracious in an e-mail to the reporter:
“Thank you for including my parents as an example of ‘love until death.’ The article was thoughtful and well written. … Your article, while bittersweet to me, will be a great reminder to our family of their love and commitment.”
The couple’s daughter said Wallace Crain died the day before Thanksgiving last year and Nell Crain died Dec. 9. They had been married for 67 years.
Parker explained that he turned in his story to Express-News religion editor Arthur Santana late last summer. Santana said he edited the story, but essentially put it on hold until after the holidays. Two weeks ago, he gave the story back to Parker for updating. However, while he re-interviewed two other couples featured in the story, Parker did not seek new input from the Crains.
“I didn’t feel like Mr. Crain’s comments needed updating,” Parker said. “… They were such a sweet couple. They were what really made the story a story.”

Plagiarism at the San Antonio Express-News

Talk about burying the lead.
After spending the majority of his column chastising a television station and newspaper for lifting material from his paper, San Antonio Express-News public editor Bob Richter finally gets around to the real news: his paper recently fired a sports reporter for committing plagiarism.

…veteran E-N sports staffer Harry Page was terminated last week for lifting information — which he presented in his bowling blog as his own — from two websites: www.bowl.com, the Web site of the U.S. Bowling Congress, and www.pbatour.com, the Professional Bowlers Association Tour Web site.
The plagiarized work appeared only on MySA.com and has been removed.
Page had worked in the sports department since April 19, 1970, and was one of the first people to greet me here when I joined the sports staff in 1978. I hate to see him go out like this, but, as Editor Robert Rivard told staff, the newspaper has “zero tolerance” for plagiarism.
It was an ethics wakeup call for Express-News journalists and, I hope, will be for our brethren in broadcast news as well.

This important information should have been the main focus of his column, and it would have been good to understand how the plagiarism was discovered, and whether or not Page’s previous work was examined. The paper removed the offending articles, but could more be lurking in the archives? Let’s hope not, but it would be nice to know for sure.

Kudos to Romenesko for spotting it.