An article on March 16 profiling three sex workers in the wake of Gov. Eliot Spitzer’s resignation after revelations that he patronized prostitutes misconstrued how two of the women, identified by the pseudonyms Faith O’Donnell and Sally Anderson, said they earned a living. The resulting misrepresentation of the two women’s work included a headline that referred to them as “high-priced call girls” and a paragraph that said they practiced “the 21st-century version of the oldest profession.”
The reporter who interviewed them, one of two who worked on the article, never explicitly asked the women whether they traded sex for money or were prostitutes, call girls or escorts; he used the term “sex workers,” a term they used themselves that describes strippers and lap dancers as well as prostitutes. Though Ms. Anderson advertises herself as a “dominatrix with a holistic approach,” he did not ask her whether that meant she also performed sex acts for money, nor did he ask Ms. O’Donnell what her work actually was before characterizing it. He and the editors should have explored whether he had determined these things precisely.
After the article was published, both women contacted The Times and said they do not perform sex for money; Ms. O’Donnell refused to be specific about what she does.
Because of an editing error, the article misstated the political work of the New York chapter of the Sex Workers Outreach Project, a group in which Ms. Anderson is active; it advocates the decriminalization of prostitution, not its legalization, arguing that sex work should be regulated through labor law like other jobs but not subject to additional restrictions. Another editing error changed the meaning of Ms. Anderson’s observation that “no one” had come to an event she had helped plan to highlight difficulties faced by prostitutes; Ms. Anderson meant that no journalists had attended. Link
Editor
What I'm Reading
- Jayson Blair Addresses W&L Journalism Ethics Institute :: Washington and Lee Universitywlu.edu | November 6, 2009
- Journalism 2.0 | Mark Briggs Defining what's good in digital journalismJournalism 2.0 | November 5, 2009
- New York Times Goofs, Includes Editor's Internal Notes In iPhone News Article (NYT, AAPL)Silicon Alley Insider | November 4, 2009
- The Public Editor - Recession, Revolution and a Leaner Times - Op-Ed - NYTimes.comThe New York Times | November 1, 2009"Now, with an around-the-clock news cycle, reporters file throughout the day, and copy can be edited over a smoother cycle, she said. That is the goal, but the editing staff is dealing with much more copy than before, some online articles are now read by a single editor instead of four or five, and I hear regularly from readers complaining about errors in grammar, spelling and word usage."
- Reuters Editors Blog Archive Are we now too speedy for our own good? | Blogs |Reuters UK | October 27, 2009
- Newspapers want readers' help with Web credibility | Business news | Chron.com - Houston ChronicleHouston Chronicle | October 30, 2009
- Germany Looks at Ways to Protect Online Journalism - NYTimes.comThe New York Times | October 28, 2009
- The Future of Publishing? Trust and Curation, Says the Founder of Craigslist The Scholarly KitchenThe Scholarly Kitchen | October 26, 2009
- Bob Sutton: Reducing Interruptions and Saving Lives: New Study on Drug Treatment Errorsbobsutton.typepad.com | October 28, 2009Very good lessons here for journalists as well.
- 25 things journalists can do to future-proof their careers | Blog | EconsultancyEconsultancy | August 26, 2009
- Jayson Blair Addresses W&L Journalism Ethics Institute :: Washington and Lee University
Accuracy Sites
Broadcast Corrections
Magazine Corrections
Newspaper Corrections
- Akron Beacon Journal
- Albany Times Union
- Arizona Daily Star
- Arizona Republic
- Asbury Park Press
- Associated Press
- Atlanta Journal-Constitution
- Austin American-Statesman
- Austin Chronicle
- Baltimore Sun
- Bangor Daily News
- Boston Globe
- Buffalo News
- Cape Cod Times
- Charleston Gazette
- Chicago Tribune
- Christian Science Monitor
- Cleveland Plain Dealer
- Columbus Dispatch
- Contra Costa Times
- Dallas Morning News
- Daytona Beach News-Journal
- East Valley Tribune
- Fort Worth Star-Telegram
- Fresno Bee
- Globe And Mail
- Greensboro News & Record
- Hartford Courant
- Honolulu Advertiser
- Houston Chronicle
- International Herald Tribune
- Kent State Stater
- Los Angeles Times
- Mail & Guardian (South Africa)
- Miami Herald
- Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
- Minneapolis Star Tribune
- Minnesota Daily
- Mirror (UK)
- Monterey County Herald
- National Post
- New Orleans Times-Picayune
- New York Times
- Newsday
- Northwest Herald
- Orange County Register
- Orlando Sentinel
- Philadelphia Inquirer
- Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
- Portland Press Herald
- Raleigh News & Observer
- Reuters
- Rocky Mountain News
- Sacramento Bee
- Salt Lake Tribune
- San Antonio Express-News
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Sarasota Herald-Tribune
- Seattle Post-Intelligencer
- Seattle Times
- South Florida Sun-Sentinel
- St. Louis Post-Dispatch
- St. Petersburg Times
- Tampa Tribune
- The Gazette (Montreal)
- The Guardian
- The Independent (UK)
- The Oregonian
- Toronto Star
- U of Virginia Cavalier Daily
- Victoria Advocate (Texas)
- Virginian-Pilot
- Wall Street Journal
- Washington Post
- Washington Times
- Wichita Eagle
- Winston-Salem Journal
- Worcester Telegram & Gazette
Online Corrections
-











